A couple of months ago I talked about our new pocket money strategy for our 6 year old son. For a number of reasons, it hasn’t worked particularly effectively.
To recap, he can receive £1.50 per week (depending on behaviour), but if he saves his money for 4 weeks, I’ll boost the £6 he would have earned up to £10. The idea behind this is to a) try to get him to behave by seeing a consequence to his actions, and b) to get him to think about the benefits of saving over instant gratification.
Why hasn’t it worked?
Firstly, I don’t think we’ve been clear enough on the deal itself. It’s not something he really thinks about during the week, and it only becomes a factor when we get to a Friday and decide whether he’s earned the money.
We also have to add in the grandparent factor – if they’re buying the kids stuff outside of what they can get through their pocket money, then the system again gets forgotten about – they’ll get what they want anyway, so why worry about stingy dad’s silly allowance scheme?
Finally, in some ways the scheme has caused more problems, as our 3 year-old daughter also now wants pocket money (we feel she’s too young), because she sees the things that our son can buy with his money and wants the same.
Stopping Those Annoying “I wants”…
On a similar subject, I’ve just been reading How I Battle The “I Want” Syndrome over at Bargaineering. It gives some great tips on explaining money issues to kids, and I think there are some great tips in there which could help with our pocket money scheme.
One of these is by adopting some sort of sticker system to show our son his progress towards the 4 weeks and the £10. That would act as a more visible reminder of what he can achieve if he’s patient.
The article also looks at ways of curbing the constant “I wants” that children seem to being coming out with.The key to dealing with these, the article suggests, is to explain the value of money to them in terms that they understand:
When he wants something, I use items he already has to explain what it costs. We still talk about money, but I put it into terms of “That robot your friend has and you want would be like giving up five of your matchbox cars and your favorite dump truck, is it still something that is important to you?”
Another tip that we can definitely use in our house is the idea of “one in, one out”, when it comes to toys. When your child has something new, make them choose another toy that can go to the charity shop or be sold at a car boot sale. This will both get them to think about how much they value the new toy, and also should reduce the amount of clutter in your house (if anyone has any other practical tips on reducing the clutter of kids toys, such as other tactics for getting rid of them, I’d be extremely grateful!).
Kids can be very difficult to deal with in certain areas, money being one of them, but I think it’s important that we try to see the world from their point of view when we deal with these issues, otherwise both parents and children will get frustrated.
If you have any other experience of dealing with money issues with kids, let us know in the comments below.
photo credit: smoorenburg
- HSBC Online Banking “Back To Normal” (January 7, 2016)
- Death Of Pocket Money – More Parents Than Ever Pay Children Digitally (July 29, 2015)
- goHenry Invites Members To Invest Through Crowdcube (May 3, 2016)
- goHenry’s New Features Aim To Make Saving A Habit For Young People (January 14, 2015)
- 10 Simple Money Savers You Shouldn’t Ignore (June 18, 2016)